Skip to content
The World Can't Wait
Menu
  • Home
  • Events
  • About
    • About World Can’t Wait
      • History of World Can’t Wait
  • Projects
    • War Criminals Watch
    • We Are Not Your Soldiers!
    • Fire John Yoo
    • Sudan’s Struggle
  • Media
    • Audio
      • Video
    • Public Svc. Announcements
    • Press & Press Releases
      • Press Releases
      • Press Coverage
    • Photos
  • Take Action
    • Materials in English
    • Materials in Spanish
    • What You Can Do Now
    • Donate
    • More Resources
      • News & Analysis
        • Alternet
        • Antiwar.com
        • Black Agenda Report
        • Common Dreams
        • CounterPunch
        • Dissident Voice
        • Media Matters
        • Next Left Notes
        • OpEd News
        • Project Censored
        • Raw Story
        • Revolution Newspaper
        • Truthdig
        • Truthout
      • Anti-War
        • Afghans for Peace
        • Courage to Resist
        • Drone Warfare Awareness
        • Iraq Vets Against the War
        • Peace of the Action
        • Veterans for Peace
        • Voices for Creative Non-Violence
        • War is a Crime
      • Anti-Torture/Detention
        • Andy Worthington
        • Close Guantanamo
        • Free Detainees
        • Int’l Justice Network
        • No More Guantánamos
        • Religious Campaign Against Torture
        • Witness Against Torture
      • Political Repression
        • Bill of Rights Defense Committee
        • Center for Constitutional Rights
        • Committee to Stop FBI Repression
        • Drop the Charges on Gregory!
        • National Lawyers Guild
        • No Separate Justice
        • Project Salam
        • Stop Mass Incarceration
      • Women’s Rights/Theocracy
        • Defend Science
        • Feministing
        • RH Reality Check
        • Stop Patriarchy
        • Talk 2 Action
        • Theocracy Watch
        • Walk for Choice
      • Environment
        • Bill McKibben
        • Climate Connections
        • Enviros Against War
        • Grist
        • Tar Sands Action
  • En Español
Menu

John Yoo and The Senate Torture Report

Posted on August 27, 2014
Share:
Ralph E. Stone | August 22, 2014

John Yoo authored the Torture Memos used to justify torture of human beings by the Bush Administration

Professor John Yoo stepped away from his lectern at the UC Berkeley School of Law to send an e-mail to the San Francisco Chronicle criticizing the forthcoming Senate Select Committee on Intelligence (SSCI) torture report saying that if “torture was used and it didn’t work, she [Senator Dianne Feinstein] is flat wrong.” Yoo claimed the report failed to maintain “bipartisanship” that “will undermine its conclusions.”

I suspect that this is a preemptive attack by Yoo as the release of the Senate torture report will probably place Yoo on the hotseat again.

The SSCI Torture report has been approved for public release. However, the SSCI and the CIA are fighting over the CIA’s substantial redactions to the torture report summary. The torture report is 6,000 pages, adopted by the SSCI in December 2012; it is the most comprehensive report on the CIA’s use of “enhanced interrogation techniques,” a euphemism for torture.

Reportedly, the SSCI report found that the CIA misled Congress, the Justice Department, and President George W. Bush about the “effectiveness” of torture methods such as waterboarding, shackling in painful positions, and slamming detainees against walls.

The report also reportedly found that those abuses did not help locate Osama bin Laden or thwart any terrorist plots, and were in fact counterproductive.

In addition to the SSCI torture report, there is a CIA response to the SSCI torture report defending the agency’s actions. A third report, commissioned by former CIA Director Leon Panetta, is reportedly consistent with the SSCI torture report findings, but contradicts the CIA’s response to the torture report. it is not clear whether these reports will be released.

John Yoo served as Deputy Assistant U.S. Attorney General in the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) where he drafted a legal rationale (Memo 1, Memo 2) for “enhanced interrogation techniques” which included stress positions, sleep deprivation, and simulated drowning known as “waterboarding.” The memorandum were signed off on by Assistant Attorney General Jay S. Bybee, head of the Office of Legal Counsel of the U.S. Department of Justice. Yoo, stretching the unitary executive theory, argued that Bush’s executive powers gave him the right in the U.S. “war on terror” to authorize the use of torture. And he further argued that the president was above the law and under certain circumstance was in control of the other branches of government.

In addition, the memos argued that criminal law doesn’t prohibit torture because it doesn’t apply to the military. Treaties and the War Crimes Act don’t prohibit torture because they only apply to uniformed enemy soldiers. And federal statutes prohibiting torture don’t prohibit torture because they don’t apply to conduct on military bases.

In 2003, following the accounts of the torture and prisoner abuse at Abu Ghraib in Iraq, Yoo wrote another memo concluding “that federal laws against torture, assault and maiming would not apply to the overseas interrogation of terror suspects.” This was used as justification for the abusive treatment of prisoners at the Guantánamo Bay detention camp.

After releasing the torture memos, President Barack Obama acknowledged that “we tortured some folks.” Obama repudiated these memos on January 22, 2009.

John Yoo, in spite of the near universal understanding among thinking people that these techniques, especially waterboarding, constituted torture write such justifications for their use, which led inevitably to the abuses at Abu Ghraib, Guantánamo Bay, and the extraordinary rendition program (secret abductions and transfers of prisoners to other countries where torture was used). By using torture, we lost any ideological advantage we might have had– the promotion of democracy, freedom and human rights. We become the thugs our enemies say we are. John Yoo bears some responsibility for the inevitable consequences of his memos laying a “legal” basis for the U.S. use of torture

All misdeeds, however, do not go unrewarded. This year, Yoo was awarded an endowed faculty chair at University of California Berkeley School of Law. He has much to teach the future lawyers of America.

In July 2014, U.C. Berkeley students, alumni and a group of lawyers in the Bay Area initiated an online petition to rescind UC Berkeley School of Law professor John Yoo’s recent faculty chair endowment. The release of the SSCI torture report should provide additional weight to this petition drive.

I look forward to the release of the SSCI torture report.

This article originally appeared at fogcityjournal.com.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Because humanity & the planet come first...
store
Don’t stop… Don’t conciliate... Don’t accommodate... Don’t collaborate... and support World Can't Wait.

Sign up for email

Stop FBI Repression
Know your rights
If An Agent Knocks

About

World Can't Wait mobilizes people living in the United States to stand up and stop war on the world, repression and torture carried out by the US government. We take action, regardless of which political party holds power, to expose the crimes of our government, from war crimes to systematic mass incarceration, and to put humanity and the planet first.

Read More

Subscribe to E-Newsletter

Contact World Can't Wait

TOPICS

  • Afghanistan & Pakistan
  • Covert Drone War
  • Crimes are Crimes
  • Culture of Bigotry
  • Environment
  • G.I. Resistance
  • Haiti
  • Immigrants
  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • Libya
  • Mass Incarceration
  • Obama
  • Occupy
  • Palestine
  • Police State Repression
  • Real History Lessons
  • Reproductive Rights
  • Reports on Protest & Resistance
  • Theocracy
  • Torture
  • Wikileaks
  • Calls to Action
  • The Expanding War on the World

Projects

  • War Criminals Watch
  • We Are Not Your Soldiers
  • Get Involved

  • Donate
  • Download filters, stickers and posters
  • More ways to get involved
  • ©2025 The World Can't Wait | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme